Is It Better to Repair or Replace Your Washing Machine?

Blog author image
Michael Foster
July 11, 2024
Home appliances
Blog post image
The dilemma of whether to repair or replace a washing machine centers around weighing the cost of fixing the current appliance against the potential benefits of investing in a new one. Factors like the age of the machine, the extent of damage, repair costs, and energy efficiency play crucial roles.
Repairing may be cost-effective for minor issues on relatively new machines, while older, less efficient models may warrant replacement to save on long-term expenses and energy consumption. Ultimately, the decision hinges on balancing immediate financial outlay with long-term benefits.

Assessing the Damage: When to Repair

  • Signs that your washing machine can be repaired:
  1. Unusual Noises: If your washing machine starts making loud or unusual noises during its cycle, it could indicate a problem with the motor, bearings, or other components. These issues are often repairable.
  2. Leaking Water: If you notice water leaking from your washing machine, it's important to address it promptly. Leaks can result from damaged hoses, faulty seals, or a clogged drainage system, all of which can be repaired.
  3. Not Draining Properly: If your washing machine isn't draining water properly after a wash cycle, it could be due to a clogged pump, a blocked drainage hose, or a malfunctioning drain pump. These issues can usually be repaired by a technician.
  4. Shaking or Vibrating Excessively: Excessive shaking or vibrating during the spin cycle can indicate an unbalanced load, but it can also indicate issues with the drum, suspension springs, or shock absorbers. These components are typically repairable.
  5. Error Codes or Malfunctions: Modern washing machines often display error codes when they encounter issues. If you see error codes on your machine's display or if it stops working unexpectedly, it's a good indicator that there may be a repairable problem with its electronics, sensors, or control board.
  • Cost-effective repairs and their benefits:
  1. Reduced Expenses: Fixing your washing machine is generally more economical than purchasing a brand-new one, leading to substantial short-term cost savings.
  2. Extended Lifespan: Fixing the machine can extend its usable life, allowing you to get more value from your initial investment.
  3. Environmental Impact: Repairing reduces electronic waste and contributes to a more sustainable lifestyle, as disposing of appliances prematurely can harm the environment.
  4. Familiarity: You're already familiar with your current machine's operation, which eliminates the learning curve associated with a new one.
  5. Immediate Solution: Repairs often provide a quick solution, avoiding the inconvenience of shopping for a new washing machine and waiting for delivery.

The Aging Factor: When to Consider Replacement

  • Understanding the lifespan of washing machines:
  1. Average Lifespan: Washing machines typically have an average lifespan of 10-15 years. Knowing the age of your appliance is crucial in deciding whether to replace it.
  2. Manufacturing Quality: The quality of manufacturing varies, so some machines may last longer while others may degrade sooner.
  3. Frequency of Use: How often you use your washing machine can impact its longevity. Machines used more frequently may wear out faster.
  • Signs of irreparable damage of washing machine:
  1. Severe Structural Damage: If your washing machine has suffered significant structural damage, such as a bent or cracked drum, chassis, or frame, it may be beyond repair. These types of damage can compromise the machine's integrity and safety.
  2. Motor Failure: When the washing machine's motor burns out or seizes, it can be a costly repair. If the motor is severely damaged or if it would cost a substantial amount to replace, it might be more economical to replace the entire machine.
  3. Burnt or Melted Wiring: Electrical issues like burnt or melted wiring can pose serious safety hazards. If you discover such damage within your washing machine, it's advisable to consider replacing it, as repairing electrical problems of this nature can be complex and expensive.
  4. Multiple Component Failures: If your washing machine experiences simultaneous failures of multiple critical components, such as the motor, transmission, and control board, the cost of repairing all these parts might outweigh the value of the appliance. In such cases, replacement could be more cost-effective.
  5. Extensive Rust or Corrosion: If your washing machine has extensive rust or corrosion, especially in crucial parts like the drum, it may be irreparably damaged. Rust can weaken the structural integrity and lead to further problems down the line, making repair impractical.

Environmental Impact: A Factor to Weigh In

When deciding between repairing and replacing a washing machine, considering the environmental impact is crucial. Repairing your existing machine is often the eco-friendly choice, as it reduces electronic waste and conserves resources. Additionally, it extends the appliance's lifespan, reducing the need for manufacturing new ones.
On the other hand, new washing machines often come with energy-efficient features, such as water and energy-saving settings, which can lead to lower carbon emissions and reduced utility bills over time. Balancing these factors helps make a more sustainable choice.

Budgetary Considerations: Repair vs. Replacement

When deciding to repair or replace a washing machine, it's essential to evaluate the costs involved. Repairing may seem cost-effective initially, but consider long-term financial implications. Repairs might become frequent and add up, while older machines tend to be less energy-efficient, resulting in higher utility bills.
On the other hand, investing in a new machine with energy-saving features can lead to lower operational costs over time. Balancing upfront repair expenses with potential future savings helps make a financially prudent choice.

DIY Repairs: Pros and Cons

  • Assessing the feasibility of fixing issues yourself:
  1. Cost Savings: DIY repair services can save money on labor costs, especially for minor issues like clogs or loose parts.
  2. Convenience: You can address problems on your schedule without waiting for a technician's availability.
  3. Learning Experience: DIY repairs offer a chance to learn about your appliance and enhance your skills.
  • Risks and benefits of DIY repairs:
1. Risks:
- Further Damage: Inexperienced repairs may worsen the problem.
- Safety: Risk of electrical or mechanical hazards if not done correctly.
- Voided Warranty: DIY repairs might void any existing warranties.
2. Benefits:
- Quick Fixes: Immediate solutions for simple problems.
- Cost Control: Ability to choose affordable replacement parts.
- Empowerment: Self-sufficiency and confidence in handling minor repairs.

Professional Repairs: When to Call in the Experts

  • Identifying problems beyond your expertise:
  1. Complex Issues: Professional help is warranted for complex problems like motor or control board failures.
  2. Safety Concerns: Electrical or gas-related issues pose safety risks for untrained individuals.
  3. Limited Knowledge: Lack of expertise may lead to misdiagnosis and ineffective repairs.
  • Hiring professional services and their advantages:
  1. Experience: Experts have the knowledge and experience to diagnose and fix problems accurately.
  2. Safety: Trained technicians ensure repairs are conducted safely, reducing risks.
  3. Warranty Preservation: Professional appliance repairs often come with warranties, protecting your investment.
  4. Time-Efficiency: Prompt service minimizes downtime and inconvenience.

Technological Advancements in Washing Machines

Modern washing machines come equipped with an array of cutting-edge features, including smart technology and eco-friendly options, designed to streamline your laundry experience. Staying informed about these advancements can greatly influence your decision to repair or replace your old machine, as newer models may offer improved convenience, efficiency, and functionality.

Energy Efficiency and Sustainability in New Models

When weighing the choice between repairing an old washing machine or purchasing a new one, it's essential to consider the energy efficiency of newer models. Upgrading to a machine with high energy efficiency not only benefits the environment by reducing resource usage but also helps lower your utility bills, making it a financially sound choice in the long run.

Considering Future Needs: Upgrading for Added Features

As washing machine technology continues to evolve, it's worth contemplating your future laundry requirements. Whether you anticipate needing a larger drum capacity, faster spin speed, or specialized wash cycles, upgrading to a newer model can enhance your laundry routine by providing added convenience and efficiency tailored to your evolving needs.

Consumer Trends: What Others Are Doing

Understanding prevailing consumer preferences can offer valuable insights into your decision-making process. Monitoring whether people are leaning towards repairing older machines for a vintage feel or embracing the latest models with cutting-edge technology can help you align your choice with the prevailing trends and make a decision that suits your lifestyle.

Extended Warranties: Ensuring Longevity

For those inclined towards purchasing a new washing machine, exploring extended warranties is essential. These warranties provide peace of mind by offering comprehensive coverage, safeguarding your investment for an extended period. Examining the terms and conditions of these warranties ensures that you are well-prepared for any potential issues and helps maximize the longevity of your appliance.

Donating or Recycling Old Appliances

Making an environmentally responsible choice doesn't end with the decision to replace or repair your machine. Proper disposal is equally crucial. Donating or recycling your old appliance reduces electronic waste and contributes to a greener planet, ensuring that your old machine doesn't end up in a landfill and minimizing its environmental impact.

Get Washing Machine Repair You Can Trust

When it's time to repair your washing machine, look no further than Home Alliance. We offer convenient same-day and next-day appointment options. Our skilled technicians are licensed and bring years of experience to ensure you receive top-quality service. Trust us for swift and reliable appliance repairs to get your washing machine back in working order.


  • How long do washing machines typically last?
Typically, washing machines last around 10 to 15 years, depending on usage and maintenance.
  • Is it possible to repair modern, high-tech washing machines?
Yes, professional technicians can repair modern washing machines, but availability of parts may vary.
  • What are the environmental impacts of replacing appliances frequently?
Frequent replacements contribute to electronic waste; recycling old appliances helps mitigate environmental impact.
  • Are there government programs for recycling old appliances?
Some regions offer appliance recycling programs; check with local authorities for available options.
  • How can I ensure the longevity of my new washing machine?
Regular maintenance, following manufacturer guidelines, and addressing issues promptly can prolong the life of your washing machine.